Skip to content

Handbook 3Chapter 6 of 8

Past Performance, Case Studies and References

Past performance tells evaluators how risky you are. Learn what they check, how to choose and write up projects with results, how to prepare references and questionnaires, and how to compete when your record is thin.

16 min readUpdated All levels

Key takeaways

  • Past performance is about risk: evaluators judge how relevant your work is (scope, size, complexity), how recent it is and how well you performed.
  • Submit fewer, stronger projects, say explicitly why each is relevant, and describe results rather than duties.
  • No record is not a dead end: under federal rules an offeror with no relevant past performance gets a neutral rating, and subcontracts, key personnel, commercial work and teaming partners can all help.
  • Brief every reference before you list them, and manage past performance questionnaires like a deadline.
  • In low-bid procurements past performance is usually checked as part of responsibility rather than scored, but a poor record can still cost you the award.

Past performance is the evidence that you have done similar work well, and in most best-value proposals it is one of the most heavily weighted factors after the technical approach. Evaluators use it to predict risk: a strong, relevant record builds confidence, a weak or irrelevant one creates doubt. This chapter explains what evaluators look for, how to choose and write up projects with measurable results, how to prepare references and past performance questionnaires, and what to do when you have little or no past performance.

Your best proof points also feed the executive summary and the technical approach. Fill-in forms are in Past Performance and Resume Templates.

What is past performance in a proposal?

Past performance is a specific set of contracts you select to show how well you performed on work like this. It is not the same as experience, which is everything your company and people have done. A firm with twenty years of experience can have little relevant past performance for a particular bid, and a young firm can have a short but highly relevant record.

Evaluators assess it from two directions: what you tell them and what they find themselves. On federal work that includes official evaluations in CPARS (the Contractor Performance Assessment Reporting System) and answers from your references. State and local agencies call references, send questionnaires and check their own records. New York City agencies, for example, record vendor performance evaluations in PASSPort, where an unsatisfactory overall rating is entered as a caution (see New York City Vendor Registration).

How past performance counts under different award methods
How past performance counts under different award methods
Award methodHow past performance is usedWhat it means for you
Low-bid IFBNot scored; the agency confirms the low bidder is responsible, which can include its performance recordKeep your record clean and references current: a poor history can cost you the award even at the lowest price
LPTARated acceptable or unacceptableShow clearly that you meet the threshold; extra projects add little
Best-value tradeoffRated for relevance and quality, often as a confidence ratingChoose and write projects to win: relevance, results and strong references
State and local best-value RFPsUsually a scored criterion such as experience, references or past performanceMatch the RFP's format and count, and make relevance obvious

New York State law, for example, defines a responsible vendor partly by its past performance and awards service contracts on best value: the offer that optimizes quality, cost and efficiency.

What evaluators look for: relevance, recency and quality

Most solicitations define relevance by scope, size and complexity, and set a recency window. Read those definitions closely: they tell you exactly how your projects will be judged.

The relevance tests, and how to pass each one
The relevance tests, and how to pass each one
TestWhat evaluators askHow to show it
ScopeWas it the same kind of work?Map the project's tasks to the new scope of work, by section number where you can
SizeSimilar value, staff or volume?Give total and annual value, staff count, sites, users or transaction volumes
ComplexitySimilar challenges?Name them: many sites, 24/7 operations, regulated data, tight deadlines
RecencyRecent enough to count?Give start and end dates; lead with ongoing or recently completed work
RoleDid your company do the work?State whether you were prime, subcontractor or joint venture partner, and your share
QualityHow well did you perform?Results, ratings, renewals and options exercised, plus references who will say so

Many federal evaluations rate each reference for relevance (from very relevant to not relevant), then assign an overall confidence rating in your ability to perform. The solicitation sets the recency window, often three to five years. As of 2026, federal agencies may use official performance evaluations from within three years of the work's completion, or six years for construction and architect-engineer contracts.

How to choose which projects to submit

Submit exactly the number of projects the solicitation asks for, no more. Then pick the set that together covers the most of the new scope, with the strongest results and the most reliable references.

  1. Step 1: List every candidate

    Pull every contract, subcontract and significant commercial job from the last five to seven years, with values, dates, scope and contacts.

  2. Step 2: Screen for eligibility

    Drop anything outside the recency window or excluded by the solicitation. Check whether it accepts work by subcontractors, teaming partners or key personnel.

  3. Step 3: Score relevance and performance

    Rate each candidate 1–5 on scope, size, complexity and recency, plus the strength of its results and reference.

  4. Step 4: Cover the scope as a set

    Two medium projects that span every task area can beat one large project that covers half of it.

  5. Step 5: Confirm the references

    Call each reference before you commit. One who has retired, moved agencies or barely remembers your work is a risk.

Worked example: choosing three projects for a city parks maintenance RFP (scores 1–5, fictional projects)
Worked example: choosing three projects for a city parks maintenance RFP (scores 1–5, fictional projects)
CandidateScopeSizeComplexityRecencyResults and referenceTotal
County parks grounds maintenance, $1.2M a year, ongoing5545423
School district athletic fields, $400K a year, ended 20254335520
Corporate campus landscaping, $650K a year, ongoing3435520
Town snow removal subcontract, $90K, ended 20212122310

The top three go in. Together they cover grounds, athletic turf and large-site landscaping, all are recent, and two references are public agencies. The snow removal job is small, old and off-scope, so it stays out.

How to write a past performance write-up with results

Follow the solicitation's format exactly; many provide a form. When you have room for narrative, use the same structure for every project so evaluators can compare quickly:

  1. Contract facts: customer, contract number and type, value, period of performance, your role and a point of contact.
  2. The challenge: what the customer needed and what made it hard.
  3. What you did: the work you performed, in the new solicitation's terms.
  4. Results: measurable outcomes, ratings, renewals and problems solved.
  5. Relevance: one or two sentences tying the project to the new scope, size and complexity.
Weak exampleWeak write-up

“Facilities support services for a state agency. Ace Facility Group provided janitorial, maintenance and grounds services in accordance with the contract. Our team performed all tasks professionally and to the customer's satisfaction.”

Why it is weak: no size, dates or role; duties instead of results; an unproven claim of satisfaction; and no link to the new bid.

Strong exampleStrong write-up

“Facilities support, state office campus (2023–present). Prime contractor, $2.4M a year, firm fixed price. The agency needed one vendor to replace three contracts across six buildings (610,000 square feet) without disrupting 24/7 operations in its data center building. We consolidated janitorial, preventive maintenance and grounds work under one manager and introduced mobile work orders with photo verification. Results: work-order backlog cut from 340 to under 40 in six months, 98% of preventive maintenance completed on time, and the first option year exercised early. Relevance: the same three service lines, similar square footage and the same 24/7 critical-site constraint as Section C.3 of this RFP.”

Why it is strong: complete facts, measurable results, the hard part named and relevance spelled out against the new scope.

Template

Past performance project write-up

One write-up per project, in the order evaluators compare them. Use the solicitation's own form instead whenever it provides one. A longer project profile, a case study and resume formats are in Past Performance Templates.

When to use it

Best-value and points-based RFPs that ask for project descriptions or case studies, and as the master record in your past performance library.

[PROJECT TITLE], [CUSTOMER NAME]
Contract number: [CONTRACT NUMBER]   Type: [CONTRACT TYPE]
Period of performance: [START DATE] to [END DATE OR ONGOING]
Value: [TOTAL VALUE] ([ANNUAL VALUE] per year)
Role: [PRIME, SUBCONTRACTOR OR JV PARTNER], performing [SHARE OF WORK]
Point of contact: [NAME], [TITLE], [PHONE], [EMAIL]

The challenge
[ONE OR TWO SENTENCES ON WHAT THE CUSTOMER NEEDED AND WHAT MADE IT DIFFICULT]

What we did
[THE WORK YOU PERFORMED, IN THE NEW SOLICITATION'S TERMS: SERVICES, SITES, USERS, VOLUMES]

Results
- [MEASURABLE RESULT 1]
- [MEASURABLE RESULT 2]
- [RATING, AWARD, RENEWAL OR OPTION EXERCISED]

Relevance to [SOLICITATION NUMBER]
Scope: [MATCHING TASKS AND SECTION NUMBERS]. Size: [COMPARABLE VALUE, STAFF OR VOLUME]. Complexity: [SHARED CHALLENGES].

Fields to fill in

[SHARE OF WORK]
The portion you performed yourself, as a percentage or task list; required context when you were a subcontractor or JV partner.
[MEASURABLE RESULT]
A documented outcome: time saved, backlog reduced, deadlines met, satisfaction scores. Verify it with the customer first.
[RATING, AWARD, RENEWAL OR OPTION EXERCISED]
Independent signs of good performance, such as a formal rating, an option year or a follow-on contract.
[MATCHING TASKS AND SECTION NUMBERS]
Cross-walk to the new scope of work, for example “C.3.1 janitorial, C.3.2 preventive maintenance”.

What if you have little or no past performance?

Every contractor starts somewhere. Under FAR Part 15, an offeror without a record of relevant past performance, or whose record is not available, may not be evaluated favorably or unfavorably on past performance: in practice, a neutral rating. The rule carried over into the reorganized Part 15 that agencies adopted during the 2025–2026 FAR overhaul. Neutral keeps you in the competition, but in a tradeoff a rival with a strong record can still look safer, so use every legitimate source of relevant performance.

Ways to show relevant performance when your own record is thin
Ways to show relevant performance when your own record is thin
SourceHow it can countWhat to watch
Subcontract workWork as a subcontractor is still performance, and many solicitations accept itState your role and share. On federal contracts with a subcontracting plan, a small business first-tier subcontractor can ask the prime for a rating
Key personnelFederal evaluations may consider the relevant experience of key personnel; many state and local RFPs score staff experience directlyDescribe what the person did, not what their former employer did, and secure their commitment
Predecessor companiesWork by a business you acquired or grew out of can be consideredExplain what carried over: people, systems, contracts
Commercial, nonprofit and state or local workAgencies can consider private-sector and non-federal contractsGive the same facts as for government work, in the solicitation's terms
Teaming partners and joint venturesFederal evaluations may consider subcontractors performing major or critical parts of the work, and a joint venture's partnersThe partner must actually do that work. In SBA mentor-protégé joint ventures, the protégé cannot be held to the same past performance criteria as other offerors
Smaller contractsSmall awards build a record quicklyFederal micro-purchases (up to $15,000) and simplified acquisitions (up to $350,000), as of 2026, often have lighter requirements
Federal rating with no relevant record
Neutral
Neither favorable nor unfavorable (FAR Part 15)
To request a subcontract rating
30 days
After the prime contract's performance period ends (SBA rule)
For the prime to provide it
15 days
Calendar days from your request
Federal evaluation use window
3 / 6 years
Six for construction and architect-engineer work, as of 2026

Build a record deliberately while you bid. Target subcontracts with primes who already win the work you want (see Subcontracting and Teaming Opportunities); the Contractors directory shows which organizations hold New York State contracts and which agencies they serve. Certifications can open set-aside work too (which certifications to pursue).

How to handle a bad rating or a problem project

Hiding a problem rarely works, because evaluators can find it themselves. Federal solicitations must let offerors identify past contracts and describe problems encountered and the corrective actions taken. Use that opportunity: say briefly what happened, what you changed and what results since then show the fix worked.

  • Respond when the evaluation is issued. Federal contractors get up to 14 calendar days from notification to comment on a performance evaluation, and the comments stay with it. In New York City, a vendor must answer a performance evaluation report within 15 days, with a corrective action plan for any deficiencies.
  • Address it in the proposal if it is likely to surface: two or three factual sentences on the issue, the cause, the corrective action and the evidence of improvement.
  • Show the trend. Evaluators consider trends; strong recent performance after a fix can outweigh an older problem.

Choosing and preparing references

A reference is only as good as their memory of your work and their willingness to respond. Choose people who were close to the work, such as the project manager or contracting officer's representative rather than the executive who signed, and who saw you solve problems. More reference and questionnaire emails are in the templates handbook.

Reference preparation checklist0 of 6 done

Template

Reference briefing email

A short, respectful request that gives the reference the facts they need to answer accurately.

When to use it

Before you list anyone as a reference or send them a past performance questionnaire.

Subject: Reference request: [YOUR COMPANY] proposal to [AGENCY], [SOLICITATION NUMBER]

Dear [REFERENCE NAME],

Thank you again for the chance to work with your team on [PROJECT NAME]. We are submitting a proposal to [AGENCY] for [SHORT DESCRIPTION OF THE NEW WORK], and with your permission we would like to list you as a reference for that project.

Here is what we plan to say about the work:
- Period of performance: [DATES]; value: [VALUE]
- Scope: [TWO OR THREE MAIN TASKS]
- Results: [ONE OR TWO MEASURABLE RESULTS]

[AGENCY] may contact you by phone or email between [START DATE] and [END DATE]. If a questionnaire is involved, it must go directly to [CONTRACTING OFFICER NAME] at [CONTRACTING OFFICER EMAIL] by [QUESTIONNAIRE DEADLINE]; the form is attached.

Could you confirm that you are able to serve as a reference, and that these details are still correct?
[REFERENCE TITLE], [ORGANIZATION], [PHONE], [EMAIL]

Thank you for considering it.

[YOUR NAME]
[YOUR TITLE], [YOUR COMPANY]
[YOUR PHONE]

Fields to fill in

[RESULTS]
The same results you claim in the proposal, so the reference can confirm them.
[START DATE / END DATE]
Your best estimate of the evaluation period, usually the weeks after the proposal due date.
[QUESTIONNAIRE DEADLINE]
The date in the solicitation, often the proposal due date; delete this sentence if no questionnaire applies.

Past performance questionnaires (PPQs)

Many solicitations include a past performance questionnaire: a form you send to your references, who rate your performance and return it directly to the contracting officer. You usually fill in only the contract details at the top, and you may never see the completed form.

How a PPQ moves
  1. Stage 1: Get the form

    Use the exact form attached to the solicitation

  2. Stage 2: Fill in your part

    Contract facts only; leave ratings blank

  3. Stage 3: Send to references

    Early, with a briefing note and the deadline

  4. Stage 4: Reference returns it

    Directly to the contracting officer, on time

  5. Stage 5: Confirm and track

    Follow up politely and submit any required list of recipients

Build a past performance library and case studies

The fastest way to write strong past performance is to stop starting from zero. Keep one record per project, updated at milestones and closeout: contract facts, scope by task area, metrics, awards, photos, reference contacts and a ready-to-edit write-up.

  • Capture results as they happen. Monthly reports, customer emails and closeout letters are tomorrow's proof points.
  • Request your ratings. If you subcontract on federal work, put the 30-day window to request a rating from the prime on your calendar.
  • Turn the best projects into case studies: one page with the challenge, solution, results and a customer quote, for proposals, capability statements and your website (see the case study template).
  • Publish your record where buyers look. Your free RFP Detector vendor profile has a past performance section for up to 20 projects, shown as self-reported, plus captioned work-sample photos. See Building Your Vendor Profile.

Frequently asked questions

Can I win a government contract with no past performance?

Yes. Under federal rules an offeror with no relevant past performance gets a neutral rating rather than a negative one, and many contracts, especially small purchases and low-bid procurements, do not score past performance at all. Strengthen your case with subcontract work, key personnel experience, commercial or state and local work and teaming partners, then compete hard on approach and price.

What counts as relevant past performance?

Work similar in scope, size and complexity to the new requirement, performed within the solicitation's recency window. The solicitation defines relevance, so read it, then show the match explicitly for each project, ideally task by task against the new scope of work.

How many past performance references should I include?

Exactly the number the solicitation asks for, in its format. Three to five is common in federal and state RFPs. If no number is given, choose the few projects that best cover the scope rather than listing everything.

How recent does past performance need to be?

The solicitation sets the window, often three to five years before the proposal due date and sometimes longer for construction. Ongoing work usually counts if it has a meaningful record. As of 2026, federal agencies may use official performance evaluations from within three years of completion, or six years for construction and architect-engineer work.

Does commercial or nonprofit work count as past performance?

Usually, yes. Agencies can consider private-sector, nonprofit and state or local contracts. Present them with the same facts as government work (value, dates, scope, results and a reference) and describe the work in the solicitation's terms.

What is a past performance questionnaire?

A form included in some solicitations that you send to your references. They rate your performance and return it directly to the contracting officer by a deadline. Fill in only your part, send it early, brief the reference and follow up, because late or missing questionnaires can weaken your evaluation.

Can I use a subcontractor's past performance?

Often, if that subcontractor will perform a major or critical part of the work and the solicitation allows it. Show what they will do on this contract, how it matches their past work, and their commitment to your team. Check the evaluation section, because some solicitations limit how much teammate experience counts.

Complete handbook

Download the complete handbook (PDF)

All 8 chapters, templates and checklists, ready to print or share.

Put it into practice

Search open RFPs from federal, state, local, education, private and non-profit issuers, each with the RFP Detector Score.

Find RFPs

Free handbooks

Keep learning

All guides and templates